Supergirl has appeared in many different forms throughout DC Comics history. In some eras, Kara Zor-El comes across as hopeful and idealistic, while in others, she feels more jaded and emotionally guarded. Now, Milly Alcock’s DCU Supergirl introduces one major difference compared to the comics, setting her apart from her current comic-book counterpart.
As the DC Universe prepares to debut this new version of Kara, the contrast between the DCU and the comics has become increasingly clear.
Supergirl #9 Presents a Dramatically Different Kara Zor-El
The difference becomes especially clear in Supergirl #9, written by Sophie Campbell with art by Joe Quinones. In this issue, Kara attempts to unwind after a series of recent troubles.
She returns to Midvale, reconnecting with her foster parents and old friends. Additionally, she forms new friendships with Lena Luthor and Lesla-Lar, a young Kryptonian from the Bottle City of Kandor. Lesla-Lar once impersonated Supergirl, and Kara now has her under her care. This dynamic plays a crucial role in the issue’s unfolding events.
A New Year’s Eve Party Takes a Dangerous Turn
As New Year’s Eve approaches, Kara and her friends plan outfits for a booze-free celebration. However, things quickly spiral out of control. Lena Luthor creates a liquid extract of Periwinkle Kryptonite and believes the formula is diluted enough to give Kryptonians a mild buzz. Unfortunately, her calculations are wrong. Kara accidentally drinks a spiked beverage meant for Lesla, triggering a chain reaction of chaos.
Soon after, Lesla begins showing off her powers, putting secret identities at risk. Meanwhile, Kara becomes intoxicated, flirts with a stranger, and even changes into her Supergirl costume while impaired.
The Supergirl DCU Difference and Kara’s Loss of Control
Unlike what some might expect, Kara’s intoxication in Supergirl #9 is not played for laughs. Instead, the comic emphasizes the real danger of a Kryptonian losing control while wielding immense power. The situation ultimately escalates into a destructive brawl that leaves the host’s house in ruins. More importantly, Kara understands the severity of what happened. Her anger and disappointment lead her to end her friendships with both Lena and Lesla.
This grounded, consequence-driven storytelling stands in stark contrast to the DCU Supergirl, whose emotional distance appears to stem from long-term trauma rather than a single mistake.
Why This Difference Matters for the DCU
The contrast between the comics and Milly Alcock’s DCU portrayal highlights a key creative choice. While the comics explore Kara’s growth through community and accountability, the DCU seems poised to introduce her as someone still struggling to find her place.
Therefore, Milly Alcock’s DCU Supergirl has one major difference compared to the comics: she begins her journey already emotionally guarded, rather than learning hard lessons along the way.
This approach could allow for deeper character development as the DCU progresses. For fans curious to explore this alternate take, Supergirl #9 is currently available at comic shops everywhere. It offers a compelling look at Kara Zor-El that sharply contrasts with her upcoming DCU debut.
Stay tuned for the latest updates on DCU’s upcoming projects, and subscribe to DC Updates’ YouTube channel.