David Corenswet, the newly cast Superman actor, is facing backlash from fans after an old comment he made about Henry Cavill’s portrayal of the character resurfaced. Corenswet’s statement, expressing a desire for a brighter and more optimistic Superman, has sparked controversy among die-hard fans of both Superman and Henry Cavill. Let’s delve into the reactions and why fans are expressing their disappointment.
Corenswet's Comment and Fan Backlash
Social media platforms, particularly Twitter, became the stage for fans to voice their disappointment. Let’s take a look at some of the passionate responses:
“Dark and gritty? Superman (Henry Cavill) seemed very hopeful in almost every instance that he was on screen. Points being deducted, but we shall see, man.”
“Calling Henry Cavill’s Superman just dark and gritty (and not optimistic) is oversimplifying it.”
“Henry Cavill was an optimistic and bright Superman. Dude just read some dumb critic on the internet and regurgitated the ‘dark and gritty’ take. 
“
“The ‘dark and gritty’ narrative of Henry Cavillās Superman is the most overplayed, boring, unoriginal, and completely trite discussion about Man of Steel. People that canāt think for themselves use that narrative.”
“‘Dark and gritty’… Henry’s Superman flew to Mexico to save a girl from a fire… a brown girl. Other Supermans did that? Nope. I guess that makes me a fan of Dark and gritty. #HenryCavill #oursuperman #manofsteel #batmanvsuperman #ZackSnydersJusticeLeague #restoreit.”
"dark and gritty"…Henrys Superman flew to Mexico to save a girl from a fire…a brown girl. Other superman's did that? Nope. I guess that makes me a fan of Dark and gritty. #HenryCavill #oursuperman #manofsteel #batmanvsuperman #ZackSnydersJusticeLeague #restoreit pic.twitter.com/VI6O9dxMo2
— Dan Cruz (@_iambun_) June 30, 2023
Henry Cavill had similar thoughts on the portrayal, soā¦.
— Mammoth | #TheFlash Era (@MammothRick) June 28, 2023
Everything about this movie feels like it was written from a smattering of comments from the Reddit movies sub that hates that one director.
ā DrĆ¼ š (@drewexmachina) June 28, 2023
Calling Henry Cavill’s Superman as just dark and gritty (and not optimistic) is oversimplifying it. https://t.co/XQMA2HaBvX
ā Gourav Mohanty | āļøSONS OF DARKNESSāļø (@MohantyGourav7) June 29, 2023
Dark and Gritty? Superman (Henry Cavill) seemed very hopeful in almost every instance that he was on screen. Points being deducted but we shall see man https://t.co/UAxmGxPUQH
ā RoronoāOkorroo (@ChieffProdigyy) June 29, 2023
These tweets highlight the frustration and disappointment felt by fans who strongly disagree with Corenswet’s characterization of Henry Cavill’s Superman as “dark and gritty.” They argue that Cavill’s portrayal showcased optimism and brightness, evident in the character’s actions and heroic deeds.
While some fans expressed their disappointment, it is important to note that not all responses were negative. A few individuals defended Corenswet, arguing that he was simply expressing his personal preferences for the character. They believed that his comment did not necessarily diminish the quality of Cavill’s portrayal but rather showcased a desire for a different interpretation in the future.
The controversy surrounding the “dark and gritty” narrative associated with Cavill’s portrayal highlights the diverse opinions and interpretations of the iconic character.
Stay tuned for the latest updates on DCU’s upcoming projects, and subscribe to DC Updatesā YouTube channel.
