DC Studios co-CEO James Gunn is making a notable change to one of the most recognizable elements of the Superman legacy by officially removing “America” from Supergirl’s slogan. For decades, Superman’s famous motto has been “Truth, Justice, and the American Way,” a phrase that first emerged in the 1940s radio program The Adventures of Superman. In 2021, DC Comics shifted direction by eliminating “America” from the slogan altogether, reworking it into “Truth, Justice, and a better tomorrow.” Gunn later added his own variation for Superman, replacing America with “the human way.” That philosophical adjustment has now been confirmed to extend to Supergirl, following the reveal of the character’s new movie poster.
James Gunn Reveals Supergirl’s Updated Slogan
Recently, DC Studios unveiled the first official poster for Supergirl, introducing her updated slogan: “Truth, Justice, Whatever.” As before, Gunn has removed “America” from the character’s guiding mantra. Consequently, this change signals a creative shift away from American exceptionalism. Moreover, it moves toward a more universally relatable interpretation of heroism. Similarly, this mirrors the approach taken with Superman, emphasizing the hero’s humanity as their defining strength.
James Gunn and the Historical Context of “The American Way”
Although “The American Way” is primarily associated with Superman, Supergirl has used the phrase historically. The Arrowverse established this phrase as part of Supergirl’s identity in Season 1 of the CBS series. Episode 14 was even titled “Truth, Justice, and the American Way.” In the episode, Kara Danvers, portrayed by Melissa Benoist, questions what Supergirl truly stands for. This reflection leads to a moral reckoning when she confronts the season’s antagonist, Maxwell Lord.
Why “Whatever” Fits Supergirl
By swapping “America” for “Whatever,” the film fully commits to a tougher, more cynical version of Supergirl, suggested by the ending of Superman. The phrase reinforces her blunt attitude and separates her worldview from the traditionally idealistic tone of her cousin.
Gunn’s decision to replace “The American Way” with “Whatever” feels particularly fitting given Supergirl’s ongoing character arc. After Superman introduced a controversial retcon revealing the truth behind Jor-El and Lara’s message, Kara Zor-El becomes fully aware of Krypton’s deeply flawed legacy. She would likely reject the planet’s ultimate vision for its people. This disillusionment could still weigh on her in the present. It helps explain why she avoids confronting her pain and instead numbs herself on worlds with red suns.
This aligns with Kara’s trauma-shaped personality, her resistance to traditional heroism, and her personal evolution, making her first solo big-screen outing even more compelling.
Movie Details and Release
Directed by Craig Gillespie, Supergirl promises a space-based adventure in the vein of Guardians of the Galaxy. The story follows Kara Zor-El on a revenge-driven journey through the cosmos alongside an unexpected companion. The cast includes Milly Alcock, Jason Momoa, Eve Ridley, David Krumholtz, Matthias Schoenaerts, and Emily Beecham. The theatrical release is scheduled for June 26, 2026.
Ultimately, Supergirl’s new slogan emphasizes that DCU heroes aren’t flawless. Kara’s choice to keep showing up despite her struggles and imperfections defines her as a hero. James Gunn’s decision to replace “The American Way” with “Whatever” perfectly encapsulates this modern, relatable take on heroism, continuing the DCU’s trend of evolving iconic characters for today’s audience.
Stay tuned for the latest updates on DCU’s upcoming projects, and subscribe to DC Updates’ YouTube channel.
Ambily Sajan