Superman vs. Fantastic Four : Which Film Has the Higher Audience Score?

As the ongoing rivalry between Marvel and DC intensifies, fans now have the perfect matchup to analyze: Superman vs. Fantastic Four. With Fantastic Four: First Steps debuting in U.S. theaters on July 25—two weeks after Superman 2025—the stage is set for a battle of reboots. While Marvel’s latest arrives with fresh momentum, DC’s Superman already enjoys the benefits of strong word-of-mouth and repeat viewings.

Superman vs. Fantastic Four: Audience Scores Compared

Early numbers suggest a tight race. On Rotten Tomatoes, both films are holding an impressive 92% Audience Score. However, Superman’s score is based on over 10,000 verified ratings, giving it a slight edge in credibility. The Fantastic Four, meanwhile, has garnered just over 2,500 ratings so far.

On IMDb, Superman currently leads with a 7.6/10 rating, while Fantastic Four is just behind at 7.5/10. The competition remains close, though Superman appears slightly ahead for now.

According to Metacritic, the gap widens slightly. Superman 2025 boasts a 7.5 user score from approximately 1,400 users, while Fantastic Four trails with a 6.7, though this figure is based on only 104 user submissions, which may shift with time.

Superman vs. Fantastic Four: What Are Critics Saying?

The critic reviews offer another perspective. On Rotten Tomatoes, Fantastic Four leads slightly with an 89% critic score from 268 reviews. Superman follows closely with an 83%, based on 453 critic submissions—still very solid.

However, over on Metacritic, Superman pulls ahead with a 68 average critic score from 58 reviews. Fantastic Four comes in just behind with a 64, based on 52 critic reviews. While neither film is a runaway winner, the results show a competitive head-to-head battle.

The Battle Continues: No Clear Winner Yet

Although these numbers are still evolving, it’s clear that both Superman 2025 and Fantastic Four: First Steps are connecting with audiences. Positive ratings across multiple platforms show renewed interest in superhero storytelling.

In the battle of Superman vs. Fantastic Four, each film has its strengths. Superman may lead slightly in fan ratings, but Fantastic Four is holding its own critically. As more reviews come in, the true winner of this superhero showdown will emerge.