At long last, the wait is over — and Superman‘s early reactions are finally here. As expected, they’re already turning heads across the board. Interestingly, what many assumed would be a risky reboot has taken a surprisingly positive turn. James Gunn’s fresh take on the Man of Steel is earning stronger-than-expected praise from critics. Consequently, the film is now setting the stage for a bold, confident, and powerful new beginning for the DC Universe.
So far, early reviews overwhelmingly praise the film’s comic-book style, emotional depth, and standout performances. In particular, David Corenswet truly shines as Superman, bringing charm and sincerity to the role. Likewise, Rachel Brosnahan also impresses as Lois Lane, earning praise for her confident and engaging portrayal. Furthermore, Krypto the Superdog is not only delighting audiences but is even being called the breakout star by several critics.
Superman’s Early Reactions Praise Hopeful Tone and Comic Book Style
Early viewers, in particular, are applauding the film for fully embracing an earnest and hopeful tone — a clear and notable shift from the darker, more brooding style of past DC entries. Furthermore, this tonal change is being celebrated as a bold creative decision. In fact, Superman’s early reactions highlight this refreshing approach, which, in turn, has led many to draw favorable comparisons to Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man, All-Star Superman, and Justice League Unlimited. Additionally, critics are consistently praising its stylized visuals, vibrant energy, and unapologetically comic-inspired storytelling — all of which help set it apart from other recent superhero films.
“‘Superman’ is the perfect superhero movie… Watching it felt like ripping open a comic book & feasting on its wild, chaotic imagination.”
— Erik Davis (Fandango)
“James Gunn embraces the earnest, sometimes lovably corny side of comics… Corenswet & Brosnahan have great chemistry… Krypto’s the best, obviously.”
— Erik Goldman
“Hopeful, kind, a little dorky… he’s the hero we need right now. Fun, joyous, and comic-y. Adored it.”
— Joey Magidson (Awards Radar)
“Captures the empowering, hopeful spirit of the comics… delivers a hero audiences can look up to, relate to, and believe in.”
— Matt Neglia (Next Best Picture)
Cast Earns High Praise — Especially Krypto the Superdog
Leading man David Corenswet, in particular, is earning widespread acclaim for his performance as both Clark Kent and Superman. Critics consistently describe him as perfectly cast, as he brings a warm and determined presence to the role. Likewise, Rachel Brosnahan’s Lois Lane is also being praised—not only for her wit but also for her strong on-screen chemistry with Corenswet.
“‘Superman’ is a triumph for the new DC Universe… David Corenswet was born for Superman & Clark Kent. Loved it.”
— Brandon Davis (Phase Zero)
“The chemistry between Lois and Clark is red-hot… easily the most passionate superhero coupling of the last 25 years.”
— Brandon Lewis (Geek Vibes Nation)
Meanwhile, supporting cast members Nicholas Hoult (Lex Luthor) and Edi Gathegi (Mister Terrific) are also receiving positive mentions for their compelling performances. However, perhaps the most unexpected scene-stealer is none other than Krypto the Superdog. Remarkably, multiple critics have gone so far as to describe him as the “real star” of the film — a surprise that adds both charm and levity to the story.
“Lovingly captures the very soul of Big Blue… one of the most handcrafted and authored superhero films I’ve ever seen.”
— Griffin Schiller (FilmSpeak)
“David Corenswet brings such an infectious determination and warmth to the role… ‘Superman’ made me so damn happy.”
— Perri Nemiroff (Collider)
“Possibly the most comic book-y live action comic book film ever… Fully leans into the wacky sci-fi.”
— Sean Chandler((YouTuber)
Superman’s Early Reactions Aren’t All Positive — But Most Agree It’s a Bold Vision
Despite the mostly glowing feedback, Superman’s early reactions haven’t been universally positive. A few critics have nevertheless pointed out some drawbacks. Specifically, the film’s idiosyncratic tone, occasional silliness, and narrative bloat might not sit well with all audiences. In fact, one negative review even described Corenswet’s Superman as too soft.
“‘Superman’: Not the super start… David Corenswet plays a boyishly sweet Superman, constantly getting his ass kicked… The real star of the show is superdog Krypto.”
— Peter Howell (Toronto Star)
Still, despite a few criticisms, most critics consistently emphasize that these creative risks ultimately help Superman stand out. In fact, they argue that the film feels not only unique and deeply personal, but also much-needed — especially in a superhero genre that, over time, has increasingly struggled to find new life, fresh ideas, and emotional depth.
“‘Superman’ shakes the rust off of an entire genre… One of the biggest compliments I can pay this film is that it tries to be its own thing – and succeeds!”
— David Thompson (The Direct)
“‘Superman’ soars. It’s a non-stop joyride, packed with humor, action, and emotion… We’ve never seen DC like this, and it’s great.”
— Germain Lussier (Gizmodo)
“‘Superman’ is everything I wanted it to be, & a million things more… The superhero myth is not the same after this.”
— Jenna Anderson (Phase Hero)
A Refreshing Start for Superman and the DC Universe
With a tone that seamlessly blends heart, humor, and heroism, Superman’s Early Reactions clearly make one thing evident — this isn’t the Superman of old. Rather than retelling the same story, Gunn’s vision not only reboots the character but also boldly reimagines the entire DC Universe. In doing so, it shifts the focus toward optimism, emotional depth, and a renewed sense of hope rarely seen in recent superhero films.
Whether it’s Corenswet’s grounded performance, Brosnahan’s sharp Lois, or the adorable Krypto stealing scenes, this version of Superman seems ready to win over a new generation.
Stay tuned for the latest updates on DCU’s upcoming projects, and subscribe to DC Updates’ YouTube channel.